Question about hotel Melton Tiran Sharm El Sheikh (otel zakryt) 4*
Current tours to this hotel
Get the best price from travel agents
Ask a Question
Ask a question
Related question «General issues»
Is it possible that the shark bit the tourists exactly on the territory of the beach of the Tiran Hotel?
I read one of the reviews but I can't believe it.
Translated automatically from Russian. View original
Subscribe
Answers • 75
I read an interview with the victim himself and his wife. They are from Kharkov. I'm shocked! 19 fly to this hotel.
Like
You like
answered 14 years ago
The hotel near which the shark attacked is called the New Tiran Hotel, fortunately it is not THIS hotel but another one.
Like
You like
answered 14 years ago
No, this is the same hotel!!!!! It happened in front of my eyes, 5 minutes after I got out of the water! People, be vigilant, you are responsible for your own life!!!
Like
You like
•
4.5
answered 14 years ago
The photo of Kharkiv residents was taken on the beach of Melia, so this is our hotel ... We returned on the 25th. People saw a meter-long shark more than once! I swam along the reef towards Savita.
Like
You like
•
1
answered 14 years ago
Cases of shark attacks were in different hotels. The last one, yesterday, with a fatal outcome occurred in Hayat.
Like
You like
•
½
answered 14 years ago
Two cases of shark attacks on the beach of this hotel.
In the first case, the shark hurt the man's thigh, but he got out of the water himself and went for help. Many thought that he cut himself on the coral, but a few minutes later the shark attacked the second man, his left arm was seriously injured, he was already carried away in his arms, he could not walk. The shark dragged the man through the water for a long time, everyone heard cries for help, but there were no rescuers. There were splashes of the tail and puffs of blood in the water.
Before the attack, the shark swam a few meters away from a 14-year-old boy, according to him, it was about 3 meters in it ... They caught the wrong sharks.
In the first case, the shark hurt the man's thigh, but he got out of the water himself and went for help. Many thought that he cut himself on the coral, but a few minutes later the shark attacked the second man, his left arm was seriously injured, he was already carried away in his arms, he could not walk. The shark dragged the man through the water for a long time, everyone heard cries for help, but there were no rescuers. There were splashes of the tail and puffs of blood in the water.
Before the attack, the shark swam a few meters away from a 14-year-old boy, according to him, it was about 3 meters in it ... They caught the wrong sharks.
Like
You like
•
1.5
answered 14 years ago
To the post above. This is not fiction and not materials from the Internet. Close relatives were in this hotel, there is a video of what was happening ...
Like
You like
answered 14 years ago
Fear has big eyes. I don’t know the shark that crippled men in Tirana, one review says about a meter, but in our Vaives it was definitely about a meter, because it jumped out onto the pontoon after a woman and beat her with flippers and masks so that she would unhook. When the first one was caught and shown on TV, I immediately wrote that it was not the one, because they showed some kind of monster three meters away. But even a meter-long bastard was enough to chop off a woman’s hand almost to the elbow the first time. Well, some man was nearby and just pushed the woman onto the pontoon.
Like
You like
•
1.5
answered 14 years ago
I just passed a tour to this hotel, as they say, it’s better to overdo it than underdo it, bedbugs and bloody spots are a weighty argument, and then there’s a shark.(((((very sorry
Like
You like
answered 14 years ago
how did you manage to pass the ticket I am threatened with fines or a complete loss of money
Like
You like
•
½
answered 14 years ago
about the shark - however, I rested in this hotel from November 28 to December 05 (we flew home early in the morning), the attack was on December 01, 4.12 the beaches were already opened, we ourselves swam near the panton after this incident, which was after December 5=th - not I know, they say the shark attacked the German tourist again, but it is not known in what hotel it was.
Like
You like
•
½
answered 14 years ago
It’s impossible to catch all the sharks, it’s better to refrain from swimming in the sea if you can’t pass the vouchers. The people themselves are to blame, there were many who went into the water with bait, some eggs, some dragged fruit for the fish.
Like
You like
answered 14 years ago
Sharks don't eat eggs or fruit! And you are there. Press Secretary of Russian Tourism Tyurin. in general, carried complete nonsense on all the news. Allegedly, the tourists themselves fed them with meat, iren730, have you seen at least one in your hotel with a piece of fresh meat going to the beach? Do not write any nonsense after what you hear on TV, please.
Now, at last, at least more or less normal versions have begun to be spoken. About the temperature regime in the sea, at least. There, for this time of year, the water is really abnormally warm. And then they talk such garbage on TV with tongues that you think how she got into press secretaries or assistant professors at the Department of Biology of Moscow State University (he also kicked off the whole of Russia, at least wait - at least fall, about meat and tourists). Maybe Moscow State University will be interested in who knocked him out for this interview. Surely the same Tyurina promised a free ticket somewhere. He is also the chairman of the diving club at Moscow State University.
For something that would be on the ball in the sea to swim - I could not say that with a smart look.
Now, at last, at least more or less normal versions have begun to be spoken. About the temperature regime in the sea, at least. There, for this time of year, the water is really abnormally warm. And then they talk such garbage on TV with tongues that you think how she got into press secretaries or assistant professors at the Department of Biology of Moscow State University (he also kicked off the whole of Russia, at least wait - at least fall, about meat and tourists). Maybe Moscow State University will be interested in who knocked him out for this interview. Surely the same Tyurina promised a free ticket somewhere. He is also the chairman of the diving club at Moscow State University.
For something that would be on the ball in the sea to swim - I could not say that with a smart look.
Like
You like
•
1.5
answered 14 years ago
To chefmate: Well, listen to you, you will laugh so much! Straight, Tyurina is interested in this garbage about meat, that she is already ready to give away free vouchers! And about the temperature, it's even more nonsense - these sharks have been living quietly in very warm waters since time immemorial. Only one thing is clear for sure, that these events are strange, to say the least. For example, I am puzzled by the fact that so far there are no videos (or at least photos) of the events taking place on youtube and nowhere, although some eyewitnesses write that "everyone rushed to film this horror on mobile phones, etc." It's no secret that any video will always, somewhere, come up (remember that even in Lame Horse there were those who wanted to shoot). And here - zero! Strange, right?
Like
You like
•
1.5
answered 14 years ago
We rested in Tirana from November 28 to December 5. The attack on two men happened before our eyes ... 30 minutes before that, they swam on the right side of the pontoon to look at the rays and recently left the water .... they warned about the shark in advance from the wild beach, but none of the service personnel reacted ..everyone just laughed, the man could have been saved earlier. Rescuers began to move only when they saw a pool of blood around. And when you read what nonsense they write .... about the fact that they fed meat or where is the video ... you are amazed at our people, someone has grief, and give them a video ... it’s even disgusting to read. We swam on the 4th and 5th of December, it was a bit scary ... and the oldest thing is that flocks of tunas appeared near the corals, this has never happened (they swim far from the coast). Tuna is the main food of the shark. So be careful, don't rely on rescuers, they just laugh and that's it.
Like
You like
•
2
answered 14 years ago
From:chefmate To:jabetta Well, for everyone else as well. Who is Tyurin? Soap union spokesman? Not! She's a spokesperson for the travel industry. So interested vitally (and financially) in the number of tourists. And one ticket for a "good" person can be allocated. But about the temperature - if I write, then I know. I have a higher maritime education. I have been going to sea since 1978. For the last 14 years, senior assistant to the BMRT. I caught fish on half a ball. For three years he worked on the scientific vessel of the Polar Institute of Oceanology and Canography. Even a change in water temperature by 0.5 degrees greatly affects the behavior of the fish. And here the anomaly is almost 5 degrees. We have all the trawls hung with sensors. Opening, filling, stroke (depth) sensors and necessarily temperature sensors. To know the T of water in that layer where the trawl goes. So the temperature of the water matters a lot. At this time, the average T of water in the Sharma region is 22-24 degrees, and here it is 28.
Here is one possible factor. And than! No one filmed in our Vaives. Everyone either helped or fled. At least in the evening, no one in the bar was showing off a horror movie.
BRGDS chefmate
Here is one possible factor. And than! No one filmed in our Vaives. Everyone either helped or fled. At least in the evening, no one in the bar was showing off a horror movie.
BRGDS chefmate
Like
You like
•
½
answered 14 years ago
Sharks do not eat eggs or fruit. But they are full of fish. And fish is just food for sharks. That is, by feeding fish, tourists indirectly lure sharks.
The temperature was the same last year in December.
But there were no attacks. Although the White Knight of Rara74 saw and filmed the same Longimanus in the bay more than once near the pontoon. So the temperature is not the reason.
The temperature was the same last year in December.
But there were no attacks. Although the White Knight of Rara74 saw and filmed the same Longimanus in the bay more than once near the pontoon. So the temperature is not the reason.
Like
You like
answered 14 years ago
I don’t know how it is in Tirana, but in Vaives and Joyce they didn’t feed the fish. I constantly snorkeled all 8 days until 30.11, there were no langemanus, no Napoleon, no tuna. So, a pot-bellied trifle, which all its life tries not to swim further than 15 m from its coral, but still - beautiful. It is quite possible that T did not affect. Maybe she is really wounded or maimed that she cannot hunt fish. But with us it was not very large, a maximum of 1-1.3 m. What difference does it make where it came from. They should have hung nets - they should. They should have warned about the danger of an attack - they should. By the way, at the meeting upon arrival, it was forbidden to feed the fish, but not so that the sharks would not swim, but because they say the fish would become lazy and would not be able to get their own food.
Like
You like
answered 14 years ago
"someone is in grief, but give them a video ... it's even disgusting to read this" - some eyewitnesses (in particular, on the next branch) themselves wrote that there was a video, but they did not give any links. The point is not that I am so bloodthirsty (on the contrary, I can’t watch anything like that), but that you need to get to the bottom of the truth, the main thing is to know the reason and what will happen next, because. I adore the Red Sea and can't imagine rest sitting on the shore. And shootings are always, for some reason, even in the most incredible cases (that's how people are arranged).
Like
You like
•
2.5
answered 14 years ago
I don't know if someone took the picture. At least in the evening no one said anything about it. But how to get to the truth from the video? The main thing is that, without help, the guards recaptured, bandaged. And they took her to the hospital. Not even Arabs, but in my opinion a Turk (checker). I spoke to him the day before. I watch some new man walk around the territory and write everything down in a little book, and the hotel managers are spinning around him. I chose the time after dinner just as he was leaving the restaurant. He came up and asked: "Are you the inspector?" He says yes. Well, I told him about the pool with cold water and expressed it. He says: I'll note this. "So he seemed to be taking ours to the hospital. They say he drove like crazy. My friend was just going to the beach and saw how he flew from the beach and signaled to the guards to open the gate. They almost sleep there everything, especially at the gate.
Like
You like
answered 14 years ago
Well, the video, at least, can show exactly how the shark attacked - from the depths, on top, suddenly, with preparation, with circles, etc. etc. For research, all the little things are important and you, as a specialist, I think you understand this.
Like
You like
•
½
answered 14 years ago
Yes, she goes upstairs. Many have seen the fin. And what attacks - she knows only herself yet. When she is caught (if she is), then there will still be nothing in the stomach anyway. Now the news has shown that the black flags have been replaced with red ones and they are allowed to swim five meters from the shore at a depth of 50-60 centimeters. Well, that's bread. The people at least in the sea just lie down. Yes, and this bastard may not climb into such shallow water.
Like
You like
•
½
answered 14 years ago
To chefmate: It's very good that you are a specialist in the field of the sea, maybe then you can explain one thought to me (again I shoveled a bunch of material). Namely, regarding the influence of temperatures on sharks: firstly, based on what I read, it is not the water temperature that affects them, but the currents, and secondly, the abnormally warm temperature not only in Sharm, but also in other regions (although every year we we go to Egypt in autumn and the water is always warm), why did the problem form only there?
Like
You like
•
1
answered 14 years ago
We were in this hotel in August, the reef is wonderful, I wouldn’t take vouchers, and those 5 meters are enough to contemplate the beauty, you can also go on excursions, and the conditions are normal for life. So don't panic! Go ahead if you decide.
Like
You like
•
½
answered 14 years ago
Show more »