Question o Egypt
Ask a Question
Ask a question
Interesting questions
Related question «Hotel selection»
Stella Di Mare Makadi or Nubian Village? May holidays with children. The gap in the rating is crazy, the opinion is ambiguous
Stella Di Mare Makadi or Nubian Village? May holidays with children. The gap in the rating is crazy, the opinion is ambiguous
Translated automatically from Russian. View original
Subscribe
Answers • 21
Nubian village, and see what the price of Nubian Island is - a little more bonuses for guests of Nubian Island
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
I was in Stella, both times was satisfied. of the minuses - there is a sea, but far away (the pier is very long, it’s not cool in the heat)
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
If you are relaxing with children, then Nubian will be more interesting. But this is Nabq and a long pontoon, and the children will not be bored at the pool
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
Nubian Island Hotel is located in Nabq - the worst place in Sharm due to strong winds and a high coral wall with strong currents. The pontoon is really long - about 130m. Walking in the wind and back and forth for so long is extremely uncomfortable.
The Stella Di Mare Makadi hotel has an even longer pontoon - 360 m. Of these 2 hotels, I would not choose any.
The Stella Di Mare Makadi hotel has an even longer pontoon - 360 m. Of these 2 hotels, I would not choose any.
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
So this is May, already in Nabq it is very comfortable to rest in May
Like
You like
•
½
answered 4 years ago
I ask you not to cast a shadow on the wattle fence: there is Nabq to Nubians - there are short pontoons (100-150 meters is nonsense), and there is Nabq after Nubians - it’s really tough there: pontoons of 800 meters, sometimes without them at all, and there is a Nabka-hotel finish line Barcelo - there is generally the most chocolate: no currents, gentle sandy entrance, corals nearby. P / S / Tales about a strong current in a certain place = these are just fairy tales: I also saw a strong current in the hotels of Hadaba and red-black flags for days ... and for example, in Rehan, despite the currents, the pontoon is almost always open .. in neighboring Tamra - almost always closed until 11-12 o'clock. Whether you will be allowed to enter the water or not depends only on the hotel managers - on what installations and circulars they distribute to the boys on the pontoon ...
Like
You like
•
1.5
answered 4 years ago
Nubian definitely cool animation, updated the rooms, improved food, for children there are a couple of slides in the pool + the beach is very beautiful all in the fingers, soft imported sand, well, the sea itself, although shallow near the coast, but there are deep lagoons for children
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
Nubian is a terrible beach. Very narrow but deep. We rested in the Island, but the territory is common. Low tides, adults with children stand knee-deep in these lagoons on top of each other, the water is muddy because of this, there is nowhere to swim at all, it’s even impossible to get wet.
The only plus is the cool pontoon reef. We took diving there, to be honest, I saw better fish at the top during snorkeling than at depth during diving.
And in general, the wind, the red flag hung 60% of the total daylight hours.
Water park ok in the Village.
With children, it’s definitely not here (if you are guided by the sea, and not by the pools)
The only plus is the cool pontoon reef. We took diving there, to be honest, I saw better fish at the top during snorkeling than at depth during diving.
And in general, the wind, the red flag hung 60% of the total daylight hours.
Water park ok in the Village.
With children, it’s definitely not here (if you are guided by the sea, and not by the pools)
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
Sometimes it is strange to read the answers "With children not here unequivocally ", when you read the review where the hotel is rated on average by the reviewer 8.0 - one of the highest hotel reviews
"Whom the author advises the hotel: families with children; the elderly "
"Nubian Island- a very family hotel. Almost all-couples with young children "
If everything is so awful with the beach why infrastructure rating 9?
"Whom the author advises the hotel: families with children; the elderly "
"Nubian Island- a very family hotel. Almost all-couples with young children "
If everything is so awful with the beach why infrastructure rating 9?
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
about the beach lies) - I do not remember any problems with the beach, corals are poor - without the exquisite colors tskt ... but so near almost all hotels - you need to swim 300-500-1000 meters ... but many (with children) ) it's not interesting at all;)
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
9 for infrastructure, because the hotel is good. Not 10 - because there is simply no sea, and some knee-high calabans near the shore. "Very family" - in the sense that vacationers are mostly young families. It will not be possible to hang out young people there, and older people will be noisy because of the same children.
I'm not a fan of swimming pools (because there are plenty of them at home), so I have an emphasis on the sea with a gentle sunset for a child plus a reef for adults with a pontoon.
As for the reef, there are rules. Not much worse than Marsa Alam and much better than the dead reef at the Hotel Barcelo at the end of Nabq.
It seems all logical to me in the comments and feedback.
After visiting Egypt in an hour, I think, and 7 points Nubiani I would not deserve.
I'm not a fan of swimming pools (because there are plenty of them at home), so I have an emphasis on the sea with a gentle sunset for a child plus a reef for adults with a pontoon.
As for the reef, there are rules. Not much worse than Marsa Alam and much better than the dead reef at the Hotel Barcelo at the end of Nabq.
It seems all logical to me in the comments and feedback.
After visiting Egypt in an hour, I think, and 7 points Nubiani I would not deserve.
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
Barcelo also has a normal reef - no worse than Nubian so for sure)
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
It is not logical, that is. first feedback
"Whom the author advises the hotel: families with children; the elderly "
"Nubian Island- a very family hotel. Almost all-couples with young children "
Then the answer "With children not here unequivocally "
Then clarification "Very family " - in the sense that vacationers are mostly young families. It will not be possible to hang out young people there, and older people will be noisy because of the same children.
So a hotel for families with children or children is not here ?! Young families do not extinguish? So if older people are noisy why "Whom the author advises the hotel: ... the elderly "?
"Whom the author advises the hotel: families with children; the elderly "
"Nubian Island- a very family hotel. Almost all-couples with young children "
Then the answer "With children not here unequivocally "
Then clarification "Very family " - in the sense that vacationers are mostly young families. It will not be possible to hang out young people there, and older people will be noisy because of the same children.
So a hotel for families with children or children is not here ?! Young families do not extinguish? So if older people are noisy why "Whom the author advises the hotel: ... the elderly "?
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
In short, don't bother! The author asked the question, I said my own. Personally, I will not go to Nubian anymore. The reason is the lack of sea and constant winds (this was our last time in Nabq Bay). If you do not have to take as a basis, then the hotel rules.
It is not up to us to decide what people will choose.
It is not up to us to decide what people will choose.
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
Here is the sea in Nubian (though at low tide, which could be any hour of the day until 3 o'clock). Herons on their knees))
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
the question of the month of May - it's hell (in the sun) and a light breeze Nabka just a plus in this case ... and swim by the sea in Nubian can only interfere with their own complexes and laziness)
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
P / S /
- this is a photo of your reef wall from above - this is what almost 90% of photos in Sharm look like ... is this news for you? The sea for swimming / diving starts at about 100 meters ... is it difficult for you to walk 100-150 meters and calmly go down the ladder by the sea)?
- this is a photo of your reef wall from above - this is what almost 90% of photos in Sharm look like ... is this news for you? The sea for swimming / diving starts at about 100 meters ... is it difficult for you to walk 100-150 meters and calmly go down the ladder by the sea)?
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
With a 2-3-4 year old child is difficult, of course. When she was young, they rested in Marsa Alam. Here, the lack of sunset from the shore and low tide 300 m from the shore did not burden, because the hours were enough and it was possible to collect 1.5-2 hours for both family members continuously.
And you better tell me something about Stella Makadi, if you are so well acquainted. Why such a difference in rating? I see that the food is ok according to reviews. But the latest reviews, where a solid 10 points in a pandemic are a little alarming ... Aren't they custom-made?
I understand, the sunset there is even worse than in Nubian? Only a pontoon?
And you better tell me something about Stella Makadi, if you are so well acquainted. Why such a difference in rating? I see that the food is ok according to reviews. But the latest reviews, where a solid 10 points in a pandemic are a little alarming ... Aren't they custom-made?
I understand, the sunset there is even worse than in Nubian? Only a pontoon?
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
I don't know Stella McCaadi, and Stella Di Mare in Naami is a luxury hotel of a completely different level than Nubiani = that's why it's almost 2 times more expensive.
Like
You like
answered 4 years ago
