Looking ahead, I will say that Mexico lost on all fronts.
If in the Dominican Republic the hotel had a considerable territory, then in Cancun everything was more, to put it mildly, comfortable. One building with a small parking lot. This is more of a city hotel rather than part of a tourist area.
In the room: a great view of the sea, a minibar replenished daily with cola, beer, nuts, chocolate, iced tea, etc. Everything is one to one with Punta, even the bizarre presence of a sink in the room itself. There is only one difference: more inconvenient control of the air conditioner, and Corona Extra instead of the President.
By the way, about alcohol. Here the Mexican hotel unpleasantly surprised. There was a real ultra all-inclusive in Punta: real Baileys, real ballantines, real all other branded drinks. In Cancun, there were local analogues, except for Barcelona rum and tequila.
The situation in Cancun was saved only by the presence of delicious dark beer (I had never seen it anywhere before).
Below, in a small area, there are several small pools with an active show-pool program, light animation and a bunch of vacationers. However, there are no problems with sunbeds at all. There is also a snack bar with fast food.
There are no questions about food: everything is fresh, tasty and not repetitive. Here Barcelo holds the brand in all countries.
The beach is municipal, but large and quite deserted. The sea is much more beautiful in Mexico: turquoise and much cleaner. Superposition entry. You can go 50 meters to the waist, then 50 meters to the throat, and then get aground and the sea will be knee-deep for a few meters. I didn’t go further, I didn’t feel the depth.
Contingent: mostly Americans, quite a few Russians. It's funny, I haven't met a single German in a week!
The hotel has a rental office, but it's better to walk 500 meters down the street, there is a cluster of seven rental cars. Hertz had the best offer, IMHO. A large group took two cars. Aveo cost about 40 dollars, Town Country - more expensive, of course. For moving around the surrounding attractions - that's it! Everyone traveled by themselves, no organized excursions were ordered.
The STANDARD room is a room without a balcony, with a view of the rear of the shopping center and a power plant noisy under the window. There is also an ice-maker in the hallway, which operates 24 hours a day and is as quiet as a power plant. And if you get a room next to the elevator, you'll listen to that too. If there were soundproof windows, then, I think, it would be fine. The windows there are what we call cold glazing on the balcony. We lived on the 6th floor, and if you do not look down from the window, the view is quite decent. Moving to the floors above will not save you from noise, but it will improve the view from the window. The room has a refrigerator, coffee machine, cups, glasses, hair dryer, iron and ironing board, TV. There are no Russian channels, it seems. Toothpaste, brush, cotton swabs and cotton wool will be brought on request. Linen is changed every three days.
Connection. MTS and Megafon are not caught in Mexico. Catches only B-Line. Mobile communications are expensive. A call from Russia to a local SIM card will cost 2.5 dollars. It is better to call by card through a pay phone. Only buy a card with a chip, otherwise you can go crazy with a pin code. Internet in the hotel is paid. Those who have WI-FI with them can go to Kakulkan Plaza, where they say it is free.
Beach. Three small pools. There are few umbrellas. On the territory near the sea they do not exist at all. The beds are close to each other.
In restaurants, the food is normal, but especially varied. We went to a Mexican restaurant once, and the rest of the time to Don Quixote. Rations are not made on excursions. You can secretly agree with the waiter, and he will wrap sandwiches for you. Put fruits in your bag. If you leave early (before the opening of restaurants), then you can get food in the night bar, so to speak (just drinks, rolls, fruits, etc. are displayed in one corner)
We didn't need animation. Music shows in the auditorium every evening.
The contingent is varied. Lots of Americans and Mexicans apparently now living in America. There were also people from Costa Rica, England, Brazil. Americans come in groups of 15 people.
If you need a budget option for a hotel and you don’t care about loud noise from the window, then it’s quite possible to relax there. Noise is probably the only serious drawback.